All hail the great disruptor!Unless you’re Cruz, Rubio…or a Democrat


By Dr Mark Shanahan

So, it’s goodbye Super Tuesday and if we want to hang any name on your it would have to be ‘The Donald’. Indeed, as the Great Disruptor sits in his gold bath filled with asses’ milk, this morning, he probably has a huge smirk on his face. You’d think he might be pinching himself (though he’d probably pay someone to do that for him). But no, soon-to-be-GOP-nominee Trump wouldn’t go for a pinch. It might imply he couldn’t quite believe how easy this whole Primary race has been. And the Donald has never doubted himself for a moment.

Super Tuesday, when eleven states host primaries and caucuses in the race to find the Republican and Democrat nominees went pretty much to form, with the respective party front runners winning seven states apiece. That will have calmed the fears among the Democrat hierarchy, as Hillary Clinton cemented her lead, and now has three times the delegates of her rival Bernie Sanders. Finally, the Democrat race is running to form. Bernie the feisty socialist has awakened Hillary from her torpor, and her campaign, lazy and vapid at the start, has finally begun to fly. She’s the consummate professional: the Washington insider from the right of the Democrat tent. But Bernie’s popularism has played particularly well with the young, forcing Hillary into a number of policy changes to try and win some of the ground back from her opponent. There is a truism that says America doesn’t do socialism. Indeed, it’s nigh on impossible to see Bernie the popular pensioner carrying the day at national level. That looks less likely now, despite his four state wins last night, and the momentum is with the Clinton camp.

But what about the man of pensionable age on the other side? Donald Trump goes marching on. He hasn’t just lacerated the Republican tent, his outsider stance has ripped it to shreds. Okay, so ‘Little Marco’ landed Minnesota, and Ted Cruz will be mightily relieved to have held his home state of Texas and picked up wins in Alaska and Oklahoma. But as every day passes they look ever-more the also rans.

Trump, the narcissistic demagogue, may have holed the GOP ship below the waterline and the Republican hierarchy has only itself to blame. The wise ol’ heads of the GOP have allowed his policy-free, media-friendly, ranting to completely starve every other candidate of the oxygen of publicity. Even when the others have had a chance to speak, they have either been attacking Trump or responding to his attacks. For hundreds of millions of Americans, Donald Trump has been the story of the election, and the identikit challengers from inside the tent have been repeatedly buried by his bullying scorn.

Cruz will fight on, Rubio will limp into Florida and Kasich into Ohio in a fortnight. Ben Carson (remember him?) may well quit in the next few days. The Donald will preen, will pose, will peacock strut over weaker men, both in the race and in the party.

Is he assured the nomination? Not assured, but pretty close. Can the GOP fight him? Seemingly not with his rival candidates. Maybe only through the wild speculation that would see House Speaker Paul Ryan acclaimed from the floor at the Republican Convention in July. A brokered Convention? We haven’t had that kind of floor fight since 1948, but The Donald with a plurality versus Ryan the favoured son of the party would be contest of the century.

Perhaps, of course, they’ll all unite behind The Donald – that’s what he called for in his speech last night. But that would demand compromise and courtesy, shared decision making and shared authority. The authoritarian Trump doesn’t do that. Within days he’ll be back on Twitter bitching and bombastic as ever. He is the disruptor. He does politics differently. And those who don’t do Washington – and there are huge numbers in the US estranged from the political system love him for it.

Cruz is worried. Rubio is terrified. The GOP is side-lined. But if anyone should be worried it’s Hillary Clinton. Trump is making up the rules as he goes along. And if the fight for the White House is played to his tune, who’s to say he won’t win.

* Dr Mark Shanahan is a Teaching Fellow in the Department of Politics and International Relations at the University of Reading

This entry was posted in US Election 2016 (blog posts) and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to All hail the great disruptor!Unless you’re Cruz, Rubio…or a Democrat

  1. Robert Russell says:

    This is a good illustration of the present state of the US primaries. Yes, Trump really is playing the political game however he feels, as he never has been one to play by the rules. Where previous Republican presidents have either demonstrated the strength to stand on their own in ruling the country (Reagan or Bush 41), or weak enough to be used as a puppet of the party (Bush 43), Trump is sufficiently volatile that he will do as he sees fit, whether it is good for the country or not.

    Stephen Colbert made a comment last night on his talk show, “The Late Show”, simplifying the image of the Republican party’s split over Donald Trump. He generalized this by saying that on one side is the hierarchy of the Republican party and those in Washington DC, and on the other side are the voters. The voters are burnt out on the status quo, but rarely do the masses have the depth of understanding that voting in the US rarely has to do with the campaign promises of the candidates. Instead, it is the jockeying of big money donors to leverage their interests in Washington. In the end, with the game being played this way, the 99% will always lose.

    As an American, I understand the frustration of voters to want Trump, as someone who will not want to yield to the desire of the Republican establishment. But is Trump really the answer to this country’s needs? He is not even close. There is little doubt that, as he practices nepotism within his business empire, that this will not be translated into his presidency. Has he been successful in business? Yes, but he has had some tremendous failures as well, so much so that he has no qualms about bankruptcy as a strategic safety net within his tool kit. This is cannot be an acceptable option for those considering governance of any major nation. For those who have not seen this clip, John Oliver made the best stand against Trump I have seen, as of yet—

    The idea of Donald Trump as the president of the United States is a terrifying idea, and one that I hope to never see. As I am registered with neither party, I am ineligible to vote in the primaries. Nevertheless, aside from any miraculous events, I do know when the general election come around in November, the Republicans will not get my vote.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s